Reading Time: 6 minutes
As the country gets into an uncertain political and social landscape once more, Peress’ 2, 000-page document of Northern Irish life within the 1970s and 80s takes on a renewed significance
Period moves differently in the North of Ireland. Its funds heaves with the history of conflict. Walls are painted along with murals that reflect each Loyalist and Republican proclamations, the pavements in opposing flag’s colours. Stormont – the Northern Ireland Assembly that was formed with the 1998 Good Friday Agreement, getting an imperfect peace right after decades of British profession and civil unrest – sat in a state associated with decay after power-sharing flattened in 2017. This set a global record for the longest peacetime time period without a functioning government . Across those three years, vital legislation and plan on everything from abortion in order to electricity, domestic violence and climate action were stopped. Local stories, memory, and gossip morph around the North’s fug of time, tension, plus collective trauma.
“Somebody as soon as said that the trouble with the British is that they never remember, and the trouble with the Irish is that they never forget, ” John Hume, late leader of the Interpersonal Democratic Labour Party and an architect of the peacefulness process, once said. Being an Irish immigrant in London, We are still struck by the dislocation of the British State from its responsibility, and the lack of understanding, education, and collective reckoning with colonialism in the Northern by British society. It is apt then that right now, 30 years later, photographer Gilles Peress ’ documentation of the Troubles is presented at The Photographers’ Gallery in London.
The exhibit is part of this year’s Deutsche Börse Photography Base Prize exhibition. Peress had been nominated for his photobook, Whatever You Say, Say Absolutely nothing (Steidl, 2021) . It presents 30 years of the French photographer’s work from multiple stretches of your time spent in the North. Its three books are referred to as “documentary fiction”: two significant photo albums, plus a companion almanac of contextual materials, titled Annals of the Northern . Here there are descriptions of various character types of The Troubles: politicians, paramilitaries, activists, and local personas – collated in a “cast” list, like a theatrical drama. At 2, 000 webpages, it is loosely structured about 22 semi-fictional “days” – “Day of Internment”, “Day of Struggle”, “Prison Days” – from the 1970s onwards. The work is contextualised with a glossary of place names, local colloquialisms, and mini-histories.
“The famous Northern reticence, the tight gag associated with place and times, ” poet Seamus Heaney produces of the “wee six” Northern counties. “To be stored you only must save face / whatever you say, state nothing. ” Language, Peress and I agree, is every thing. At the beginning of our interview, this individual states assuredly that he calls the region ‘the North’, rather than ‘Northern Ireland’. Language is really a cultural identifier, with a fraught history and a distinctly Irish power as both beautifully constructed wording and political battleground . The “whatever you say, say nothing” title is a mantra that also appears on a notorious IRA poster that warns local people against snitching. This features in the book alongside additional posters, murals, and materials that build a capacious tapestry of life amid war.
When Peress and I speak over Zoom, language is definitely something we come back to interrogate throughout our two hr conversation – what does ‘peace’ mean to you? Faith? Whenever we speak too, it’s the morning of the North’s election results – for the first time, nationalist party Sinn Fein has won a majority . It is heralded as a brand new era. A historic selection. I describe it as monumental, surreal. I am used to the same outcomes and stagnation. “We used to say ‘not in my lifetime’. Now, maybe in my lifetime? ” he says. “Still, I will not have us hold the breath. We have much to discuss. ”
“Ireland was one of Britain’s first colonial experiments. It is a guide for imperialism. This was exactly what really motivated me with this particular book. To test the limits of time, vision, and narrative, in the face of what a state says to be true”
The region’s structures plus rituals inspire the book’s spiralling narrative – the particular imposing Loyalist marching time of year across Spring and Summer time, political peace-making milestones, commemorations for dead hunger strikers. “Time is not linear in the North. It is not in any conflict I had photographed, like Palestine. I wanted to show that recursive construction, ” says Peress. “Today is tomorrow, tomorrow is definitely yesterday, or 10 years ago. ”
Peress has spent an expansive career photographing life amid conflict, revolution, and genocide: in Palestine, Rwanda, The Balkans, and Iran, with seminal photobooks plus shows including T this individual Graves: Srebrenica and Vukovar , The Silence: Rwanda , Farewell to Bosnia , plus Telex Iran . He has honed a focused, immediate, and humane eye that expands the flattening of people and places going through conflict.
Far from voyeuristic or even reductive, Peress’ eye seems inquisitive and nuanced. It’s clear how deeply this individual embeds himself and requires interest in the communities he documents. In the book indeed, he or she references a friend who he found out years later was a British government informant. Their subjects retain agency: among the throng of protesters, a young mohawk-sporting punk peering into his lens.
“Ireland was one of Britain’s 1st colonial experiments. It is a guide for imperialism. This was what actually motivated me with this guide, ” he says, “to test the limits of time, vision, and narrative, in the face of what a state says to be correct.
“ The book is about the human problem and existence in a place which is highly ritualised simply by its never-ending conflict. The guide was essentially done in the 80s. I returned to it in the 90s – the same amount of chapters and webpages. My relationship to it provides expanded. I was there designed for internment, for Bloody Weekend, the hunger strikes. And am was there in the Short Strand for the parties for people coming out of prison 15 many years later for murder. ”
Amid the sprawling image of conflict and battle, Peress captures the variousness of people. We see Orange Order men carrying on and laughing, teenagers snogging close to army checkpoints, consuming in bars and growing plants inner-city alleys, cheeky children goading soldiers. Sinn Fein’s Gerry Adams romps on the bouncy castle. “I had to be extremely emotional and rational at the same time, ” he says.
“Every camera is both lively and deadly, it is a deep voice, ” he continues, “but I don’t have a great sense of being an author here. I think there is a death of the author here, or a multiplicity of authors, and that is important. ”
As a youthful Frenchman, Peress was able to shift across community boundaries plus capture an expanse associated with identities beyond the tribalist stereotypes applied to the Northern of Ireland. Peress delves into the layers of exigencies to our lives here. Days blur and judder with violence, riots, marching, trips to the dole office and discos, associated with mourning and craic. He or she resists the grim or even anaesthetising unrealities that much of outsider media has centered on. “ I always work from the inside out, ” he admits that, “the convergence of tradition is conflict. It is condition and religion deeply entwined. I found life and training in the people I fulfilled and the friends I produced. ”
Now, aged 74, Peress is most thinking about “gathering evidence for history”, rather than creating “good photography”. Peress was 26 when he arrived in Ulster on a single of many trips as a Magnum photographer. In 1972, he photographed the British Army’s senseless massacre of 13 innocent civilians and relaxing protesters in a civil rights march on Bloody Sunday. His images of the slain were broadcast around the globe. Bloody handkerchiefs. Approaching armed soldiers. Men, women, children, running for their lives.
“I remember shooting and crying and moping at the same time, when I saw Barney McGuigan lying dead, ” he says. He photographs Jim Wray, sat down in defiant, relaxing protest in the street. Minutes later, he would be shot dead in Glenfada Park. Peress’ courtroom testimony transcript from the Saville Inquiry (2010), which ruled that the killings were illegal after over a decade associated with deliberation, appears in the book. Brian Cameron officially apologised for the British action that season. In 2019, the Queen’s Speech would describe this kind of pursuit of justice and heritage issues as “vexatious” .
History is being re-written, language packed as a gun. Peress’ digital photography is a visceral challenge to that particular. He interrogates the limitations and liberations of visual language in capturing this type of complicated conflict, and the belief of understanding it as protracted and intractable.
“In Susan Sontag’s Regarding The Pain of Others , she describes being 14-years-old and seeing images of the Holocaust for the first time. She views life as a before and after, that will moment of witnessing the camps, ” Peress states. Sontag reflects on the spectacle of suffering: the honest, emotional, and moral associated with photographing atrocity. Impartiality is not only impossible, it’s reductive.
“There is no objective truth, ” Peress says. “Media – especially American plus British media – can be arrogant enough to believe differently. I want to make an image that functions as an open text. It is democratic. The reader provides agency to read within the intended visual language. ”
Nowadays, Peress is a professor of human rights and photography on Bard College in Nyc, and senior research many other at the Human Rights Center at University of California, Berkeley. “I have begun to consider more about visual language again with my students. We all look at the culture of not caring and apathy in community, and how visuals play straight into this. I think about visual grammar, and how that is trained, ” he says.
Sifting through pages and pages associated with Peress’ work, the weight of cyclical time and trauma, passed from generation to generation, weighs heavy. Their images hopscotch raw plus tender moments, transcending time. Though the ambition to catch such nebulous things can be worthy, this exhibition plus book feel more pertinent than ever.
The North is entering a new, unclear political and social panorama once more. “I think the concept of peace is a smokescreen. It is far from this static thing, ” he says. “It is not something which can be dealt with and put within a box here, or Palestine. The state banks on dread and a lack of imagination to find out life and structures outside of colonialism. There is no adequate rendering of reality, and that is what I have to reach for. It is about refusing to accept the story. ”